Which Raspberry Pi for a Stratux?

What the project supports, what actually differs between the boards, and what a case was cut for

A Stratux asks very little of its processor. It decodes two radio streams, serves a small web page and pushes a few hundred bytes a second to a tablet - work that the oldest supported board handles without effort. What separates the boards in practice is current draw, the heat that comes with it, and whether the case in front of you has holes in the right places.

The supported boards

From the project's own hardware list. The images are built around the 3B, which is why it remains the baseline rather than the minimum of a compromise.

Pi 3B

The baseline

What the images target. Lowest draw of the supported family, which makes it the kindest board to a marginal supply or a long day on a power bank.

Pi 3B+Recommended

The sensible default

Everything the 3B does, with better thermals and networking, still at a modest draw. For a receive-only or single-sender build there is no argument for spending more.

Pi 4BRecommended

For the full build

The board to take when two radios and two senders share one case. It draws noticeably more, so plan the supply with it rather than after it. This is what our assembled Pro units are built on.

Pi 5B

Supported, rarely needed

On the list, and the highest draw on it. Nothing in a Stratux workload asks for the performance, so the extra current and heat buy very little in this application.

Boards that will disappoint you

  • The 2B is no longer supported. It may once have booted an older image; that is not the same as being a board to build on today.
  • The Zero 2 W sits in between: our EU firmware release notes list it as tested, the project's own hardware list does not name it. Treat it as a small single-band option you accept the risk on, not as the board for a build you depend on.
  • Anything older or smaller than those is a project in itself. The money saved on the board is spent twice over on the evening it does not work.

What actually changes between them

Current draw

Rises with every generation. A supply that was comfortable on a 3B can be marginal on a 4B, and marginal supplies fail in the air rather than on the bench.

Shared USB budget

Does not rise with it. Around 1,200 mA is shared by everything you plug in, on every board in the list, which is why a faster board does not fix a dropping sender.

Heat

Follows the current. The project recommends a 5 V fan outright, because without cooling the board or the radios can overheat - and in a closed case in a sunlit cockpit that is not a theoretical warning.

Case fit

The quiet one that catches people out. Port positions moved between generations, so a case cut for one board does not necessarily close around another. Check the fit before you check the price.

The parts that matter more than the board

  • The radios. One per band, and for the 868 MHz side it is crucial that they are PPM-calibrated - an uncalibrated receiver on that band is not a weak receiver, it is a deaf one.
  • The GPS. A u-blox module is the one the project points at, generation 8 or 9 for preference, with the 7 still acceptable. This has more effect on what the tablet shows than any board upgrade.
  • The supply and the cable, which decide whether any of the above stays running for a whole flight.

The SD card, briefly

Recent builds run a read-only filesystem, so the card is not being written to in flight and pulling power does not corrupt it. That removes the commonest reason cards die in this application, but not the cards themselves: when a device stops booting, re-imaging the card is the standard repair, and it usually works.

Questions that keep coming back

Will a faster board give me more range?
No. Range is antenna, placement and calibration. The processor is not the bottleneck at any point in the chain, and no board has ever heard a signal its radio did not.
I have an old board in a drawer - worth using?
If it is a 3B or newer, yes, and it will do the job properly. If it is older, the hours you will spend are worth more than the board.
Does more RAM help?
Not in any way you will see. Buy the smallest memory variant of the board you choose and put the difference into the antenna or the GPS.
Can I move my SD card to a different board?
Within the supported family it generally just boots, because the image carries what the boards need. Check the case and the supply before you check anything else, because those are what will actually stop you.

Board list from the Stratux project's supported-hardware wiki

Disclaimer

Stratux is not certified aviation equipment. It does not replace a transponder or relieve the pilot of traffic awareness responsibilities. Use as supplementary situational awareness only. Dross:Aviation assumes no responsibility or liability for the use of Stratux devices, firmware flashing, or hardware modifications. All DIY guides are provided without warranty: use at your own risk.